On November 18, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled, by a 2-to-1 majority, that Maryland has the authority to regulate the prediction market platform Kalshi under its sports betting law. In his opinion, Judge Roger Gregory noted, “Given that gambling regulation has long been within the scope of traditional state police powers, I will not infer that Congress has superseded Maryland’s concurrent authority in the absence of a clear congressional intent.”
This is the third of four federal appellate court rulings to date that supports state regulatory authority. Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown stated on November 18 that Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as other gambling operators. He emphasized, “Under our licensing laws, gambling operators must protect customer data, prohibit deceptive advertising, and refrain from marketing to individuals subject to gambling bans or at risk of addiction. The federal Federal Trade Commission Act was never designed to provide these safeguards.”
Meanwhile, the U.S. CFTC has ordered prediction market operators such as Kalshi, Polymarket, and Coinbase to cease geographic restrictions in certain states within 30 days and resume providing services in all 50 states. However, if these companies comply with the CFTC’s directive, they will be in direct violation of a federal court order; failure to comply, on the other hand, could result in a violation of federal regulatory requirements.
A spokesperson for Kalshi responded that the rulings were contradictory, stating, “The judges could not reach a consensus on why we were wrong. This divided ruling, which includes three distinct opinions, demonstrates that there is no unified or coherent legal argument regarding prediction markets.” The company did not respond to questions about how it plans to address the CFTC’s nationwide service order.
Prediction markets are being banned in an increasing number of states, including jurisdictions such as Utah where gambling is prohibited by the state constitution. Democratic senators directed the CFTC to rescind its nationwide service requirement. Meanwhile, the industry and CFTC Chairman Mike Selig continue to argue that these event contracts are swap transactions traded on regulated derivatives exchanges, and therefore fall outside the jurisdiction of state authorities.
Further Reading
- CFTC Nominee Questions Public Interest of Prediction Markets; Legal Battle Heats Up
- Trump's Nominee for U.S. CFTC Official Faces Senate Scrutiny
- Robinhood Says It Is Unafraid of Kalshi's Stock Trading Threat; Mizuho Maintains 861 TP and 3T Upside Potential
Cover image: CryptoWallet.com Images / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Disclaimer
The content of this article is for reference only, investors should exercise independent judgment, invest with caution and at their own risk, this article does not provide or attempt to persuade viewers to trade or invest on the basis of the content of this article is for sharing purposes only, and should not be regarded as investment advice, and does not represent the Monsterblockhk viewpoints and positions, all information and views of the specific date of the judgment of the time-limited nature. In addition, if any content in this website involves virtual asset trading platforms that have not yet obtained a license to operate virtual asset trading platforms in Hong Kong, including but not limited to text introductions, pictures, promotions, events, etc., they are only available to users outside of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.
According to the Hong Kong Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing (Amendment) Ordinance 2022, after June 1, 2023, all centralized virtual asset trading platforms operating in Hong Kong or actively promoting their services to Hong Kong investors will be licensed and regulated by the SFC, and any related unlicensed activities will be a criminal offence. For more information and details of the legislation, users may refer to the SFC website.
